Transport taxes and charges (TERM 022) - Assessment published Jul 2010

Indicator definition

The infrastructure taxes and charges indicator is a complex indicator, which includes:
Road transport charges (note data is only currently available for the freight sector):

• Taxes on the possession of freight vehicles or use of road applicable only to vehicles registered in the country (nationality based road charge);
• Moderately territorial charges: time based charges for the use of road or motorway networks, moderately territorial road charges; including its minimum charge (EUR) and length of minimum period of charge (days) (freight transport);
• Strongly territorial road charge or distance charge for freight transport;
• Combined distance and weight based charges for the use of road or motorway networks applied to freight only. So far only Switzerland has implemented it.

The indicator could be expanded to include the revenues collected per country, e.g. total toll revenues (EUR) for some countries.
Rail infrastructure charges:

• fixed rail charges for freight and passenger rail;
• variable rail freight and passenger charge.

The indicator could be expanded to include total rail infrastructure charges per country as well as a sum of the total amount of rail freight charges (EUR) and total amount of rail passenger charges (EUR).
Information is currently collected for infrastructure charges as well as for total charges, but due to only a few countries submitting data, the comparison is very fragmented.

Units

Road transport:

• Nationality based charges - vehicle tax (EUR/year). It comprises the taxes on the possession of a vehicle and on the use of roads applicable to vehicles registered in the country.
• Weakly territorial charges - tax (EUR/l). It comprises fuel taxes.
• Moderately territorial charges - user charge (EUR/year). It comprises a time based charge for the use of road or motorway networks, such as vignette and Eurovignette.
• Distance charge (toll) - tax (EUR/km). It represents kilometre charges and motorway tolls.
• Strongly territorial charges - charge per tkm (EUR/tkm). It comprises distance/weight charges for the use of road or motorway networks.

Rail infrastructure charges:

• Fixed rail charges (EUR/tonne-km and EUR/train-km) for freight and passenger rail.
• Variable rail freight charge (EUR/gross tonne-km) and variable rail passenger charge (EUR/pkm).
• Variable rail freight charge (EUR/net tonne-km and EUR/gross train-km).

Policy context and targets

Context description

European infrastructure charging policy

Objectives for reducing transport congestion, pollution and the re-balancing of the modal split are reflected in the Commission's infrastructure charging policy. Transport taxes and charges should support the goal, cover the diverse modal range of passenger and freight transport, and differentiate according to the impacts of different pollution levels, travelling times and damage costs in addition to infrastructure costs. The Polluter Pays Principle is fundamentally a fair and effective way of achieving the goal and supporting the development of public - private partnerships and market liberalisation. A clear indication that user charges are successful is that they provide a direct source of income for potential public-private partnerships, and that they support liberalised markets.

The EEA report on the "Effectiveness of environmental taxes and charges for managing sand, gravel and rock extraction in selected EU countries" (EEA, 2008) illustrates that environmental taxes and charges are Market Based Instruments (MBIs) and should help realise environmental and economic policy objectives in a cost effective way. The fundamental reason why environmental taxes are commonly applied is to correct market failures and therefore ensure that the polluter pays. Environmental charges cover the costs of monitoring and enforcing environmental regimes or services.

In 2001 the European Commission published a White Paper "European transport Policy for 2010: Time to decide". The mid term Review of the White Paper has been launched in 2005-2006. The conference held in 2005 on the Review stressed that decoupling global growth from the growth of transport must not be sought but that the growth of transport must have a much more qualitative dimension, which is already largely addressed by the White Paper. Among other recommendations, the Conference pointed out that the first step to make commerce and globalization at the economic and environmental level is to introduce taxes on air and maritime transport fuel.

The European Commission released a Handbook with estimates of external costs in the transport sector. The handbook summarises the state of the art with regards to the valuation of external costs. On the basis of this handbook, the European Commission is preparing a communication on a strategy to internalise the external costs for all modes of transport, which is due in 2008, and a proposal to revise the Directive on the charging of heavy goods vehicles.

In April 2004 the European "Interoperability Directive" 2004/52/EC (EC, 2004) was approved. It sets out the principles of the interoperability of the road toll systems within the EU. It requires that the systems capable of accepting automatic toll payment badges meet the same standards as those issued in other countries.

'Eurovignette Directive'

Directive 2006/38/EC of 17 May 2006 amends the Directive 1999/62/EC with a view to establishing a new Community framework for charging for the use of road infrastructure. The Directive lays down rules for the application by Member States of user charges on roads, including roads on the trans-European road network and roads in mountainous regions. From 2012 onwards Directive 2006/38/EC will apply to vehicles weighing between 3.5 and 12 tonnes (compared to the earlier Directive which applied to vehicles above 12 tonnes) and will impose much lower basic charges.
The Directive's main novelty was to introduce the possibility for individual states to integrate the 'external costs' of road transport into toll prices. The 'external costs' can include congestion costs, environmental pollution, noise, landscape damage, social costs such as health and indirect accident costs which are not covered by insurance. To be integrated in the charges ('internalised'), the costs have to be proved "undeniable".
The Eurovignette also gives member states extra flexibility on how to levy charges. In particular, these can now be raised on the entire road network, not just motorways:

• Toll revenue should be used for the maintenance of the road infrastructure concerned or to cross-finance the transport sector as a whole.
• As of 2010, countries which already apply tolls or user charges will be obliged to vary their prices according to vehicle pollution standards (Euro standards series) in order to favour the cleanest ones.
• Authorities may decide to exempt isolated areas or economically weak regions from applying tolls or user charges.
• An extra 15 % 'mark-up' charge can be levied to finance new alternative transport infrastructure projects such as rail or inland waterways (the mark-up can be raised to 25 % for cross-frontier projects in mountainous regions).
• Urban areas are not included in these extra mark-up charges. However, local authorities can still raise them under a provision taken from Article 9 of the current Eurovignette Directive (which for instance allowed the city of London to apply such charges).
• Rebates will be possible for frequent users.

The EC is working towards a "common methodology for the calculation and internalisation of external costs that can be applied to all modes of transport" to be proposed in 2008 as indicated in the Directive 2006/38/EC.

European strategy for the internalization of external costs

In July 2008 the European Commission presented a review of the Directive as well as a 'Strategy for the internalisation of external costs', as part of a wider Communication on 'Greening Transport'.

The EC is planning to propose methodologies for all modes of transport, therefore the strategy for internalising external costs covers them all.

The Commission is proposing to make it possible to internalise some of the external costs of the road haulage sector by revising the Directive 199/62/EC in order to allow charges to include external costs such as air pollution, noise pollution and congestion, setting up Community coordination mechanisms with a common methodology and ceilings for the calculation of charges and allocating revenue to the transport sector. To be effective, tolls should vary depending on the vehicle concerned, the type of route and the time of day.

In the Green Paper "Towards a new culture for urban mobility" EC have promised to issue the Action Plan on Urban Mobility, to be proposed in autumn 2008. The Commission's proposal for the Action Plan includes three measures: amending the registration tax, setting up a system for refunding it, and restructuring the tax base for the registration tax and the annual road tax to establish a full or partial link with CO2 emissions.

Directive 2001/14/EC allows internalisation of rail external costs. The Directive only, however, allows internalisation if there is an equivalent cost increase for competing modes of transport (i.e. road freight and road passenger transport). Revising Directive 1999/62/EC will enable internalisation of external costs in the road transport sector without a corresponding increase in the rail sector, which will improve the competitiveness of rail transport. The Commission is also preparing a Communication on incentives for reducing rail noise levels and may propose related legislation by the end of 2008 when it reviews the first railway package.

On 24 January 2007, the Commission put forward a proposal for a Directive on airport charges. The suggested amendments relate to the inclusion of differentiated charging on the basis of environmental damage. The application throughout the EU of a common set of basic rules with regard to airport charges will ensure fair play between the aviation partners when defining the parameters for the use of airport infrastructure. The proposal is limited to the definition of a minimum of rules to be respected when Member states and/or airport operators determine the levels of airport charges.

There is no overarching pollution control policy linked to maritime and inland waterway transport infrastructure. However, the International Maritime Organisation at its 59th session in July 2009 agreed to disseminate a package of interim and voluntary technical operational measures to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from international shipping; and also agreed a work plan for further consideration at future meetings of proposed market based instruments to provide incentives for the shipping industry. The Commission does, however, wish to include the maritime sector in the post-2012 agreement on preventing climate change. There are future revision plans to internalise external costs of inland waterways as well as indicated in the NAIADES Communication . It points out that this could revitalise inland waterway transport and would make it possible to fund infrastructure development projects in the sector.

The Commission will carry out an evaluation of these measures in 2013 and draw up a report on the progress made towards internalising external costs.

Targets

No targets have been specified.

Related policy documents

• 2004/52/EC
  Directive 2004/52/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29 April 2004 on the interoperability of electronic road toll systems in the Community
• COM (2001) 370 final. European transport policy for 2010.
  WHITE PAPER European transport policy for 2010: time to decideCOM (2001) 370 final
• COM(2003) 488
  Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Directive 1999/62/EC on the charging of heavy goods vehicles for the use of certain infrastructures, COM(2003) 488
• COM(2006) 6
  Communication from the Commission on the Promotion of Inland Waterway Transport “NAIADES”: An Integrated European Action Programme for Inland Waterway Transport. COM(2006) 6 fina
• COM(2006) 820
  Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on Airport Charges, 2007/0013(COD), COM(2006) 820final
• COM(2007) 551
  Towards a new culture for urban mobility, Green Paper, {SEC(2007) 1209}, COM(2007) 551 final
• COM(2008) 433
  Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament and the Council on Greening Transport, COM(2008) 433 final, Brussels, 8 July 2008.
• COM(2008) 435
  Strategy for the internalization of external costs. Communication from the Commission. COM(2008)435
• COM(2008) 436
  Proposal for a Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council amending Directive 1999/62/EC on the charging of heavy goods vehicles for the use of certain infrastructures COM(2008) 436

Methodology

Methodology for indicator calculation

Infrastructure charges and tolls are in Euros per standard period of time (a year for toll stickers) or minimum available period of time (such as a day for vignettes). Toll road charges are provided in an average charge per kilometre.
Methodology for calculating non-fuel related transport taxes and charges have been taken from the International Transport Forum (former ECMT) and Ecosys.

Methodology for gap filling

No gap filling has been used in this analysis.

Methodology references

Uncertainties

Methodology uncertainty

Reporting and registering rail charges is constrained due to the different charging mechanisms between countries. This therefore makes a comparison between countries difficult. The same issue also arises with road haulage.

Data sets uncertainty

There is currently no data available for passenger transport. It is important that this is collected for future indicator updates. In addition, there is data for missing for road haulage and the rail sectors.

Rationale uncertainty

No uncertainty has been specified